0
AVG Days on Market0
AVG Showings to Lease a Property0
AVG HRS Response Time0%
Renewal Rate0
Number of Happy ClientsWe offer results-oriented, client-centered Peyton property management.
Colorado Realty and Property Management brings 20 years of experience to landlords and investors in Peyton, helping property owners get the most from their single family rental homes in one of the fastest-growing corridors of El Paso County. Our founder and Managing Broker holds the prestigious Master Property Manager (MPM) designation from the National Association of Residential Property Managers, one of the highest credentials in the property management industry.
We handle tenant screening, rent collection, maintenance coordination, and legal compliance so property owners can enjoy the benefits of owning a rental without the day-to-day stress. Our communication, responsiveness, and attention to detail have earned us recognition as one of Colorado's top property management companies, backed by hundreds of positive reviews from the owners and tenants we serve.
What Our Clients Are Saying
We have been managing properties since 2006.
Rated ThreeBest Property Management Company since 2020
Best of 2025 BusinessRate Award
LOC8NEARME Recommends
Peter Lohmann's Newsletter Top 20 Largest Companies 2024 Property Management
Top 3 2024 Best of Mile High Award
Not sure if you need property management? Ask yourself these questions:
LAWS AND REGULATIONS
- Are you up to date on the ever-changing Fair Housing laws, legislation regarding Warranty of Habitability, lead based paint testing and toxic mold policies?
- Has your property been issued a current Rental Housing License? If not, are you aware of the penalties?
- Are you familiar with the new laws and legislation affecting your property?
- Do you understand the complex nature of service, companion and emotional support animals?
- Are you concerned about the recent legalization of marijuana and how this impacts you as the Landlord and your property?
- Do you clearly understand the laws regarding security deposit dispositions and the interest due to the tenant?
- Are you concerned about the possibility of a tenant suing you…and winning? It’s happening more and more every day.
TENANTS AND COLLECTING RENT
- Do you want to deal with late payments, bounced checks, and collecting rent in general?
- Do you dread confrontation with tenants? How are they maintaining the property? Are they paying their rent on time?
ADVERTISING YOUR RENTAL
- Do you cross your fingers, hoping that you won’t have to deal with the exhaustive move-out, advertising, and move-in processes that occur between tenants?
- Do you struggle with advertising and showing your vacant property?
TENANT SCREENING
- Are you prepared to take applications, run credit, and perform background checks?
- Do you have a way to screen potential tenants<?
MAINTENANCE ISSUES
- Are you frustrated with the calls and fines by the Homeowners Association or the City of Denver for something that you didn’t know about?
- Do you sometimes feel that you spend too much of your time collecting checks, paying vendors, and performing all of the accounting necessary on your rental?
Property Owners & Investors
How Can We Help?
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the potential rental value of your Colorado home?
Why Peyton Is a Great Investment for Rental Property Investors
Peyton offers several advantages for real estate investors focused on single family homes:
Rapid Growth Along the Front Range: The greater Peyton and Falcon area has been one of the fastest-growing corridors in El Paso County, with new residential development continuing to expand the local renter pool.
Newer Housing Stock: Much of the area's housing was built from the early 2000s onward, giving investors access to newer single family homes that tend to require less maintenance and appeal to tenants looking for modern finishes.
Rural and Suburban Appeal: Peyton offers a mix of larger acreage properties and newer subdivisions, drawing renters who want more space, room for animals, or a quieter, more rural setting while still commuting into Colorado Springs.
Family Friendly Community: Served primarily by District 49 schools and community amenities like Antler Creek Golf Course, the area attracts families looking to settle into a growing suburban and rural community.
Hot Market Conditions: Zillow currently rates Peyton's rental market as hot, one of the strongest demand ratings in the region, reflecting continued renter interest even as rents adjust.
Maximize your rental income
Get a FREE Rental Market Analysis to see what your property can earn in today’s market.
Peyton Rental Market Snapshot
Peyton's single family rental market is active, with Zillow rating it as hot. Rents are down from both last month and last year, giving investors an opportunity to price competitively in a market Zillow still considers in strong demand.
Average Rent: Zillow data shows the average rent for houses in Peyton is approximately $2,525 per month, down $175 month-over-month and down $75 year-over-year.
Typical Rental Range: House rentals range from $650 to $5,000 per month, with the largest concentration of listings priced between $2,400 and $3,100.
Rental Demand Indicators: Zillow classifies the Peyton rental market as hot, with 49 available rentals and an average of 63 days on market.
These market stats are from September 2026. For current Peyton rental stats, especially for single family homes, visit Zillow.
